With county and district council elections happening on 6th May 2021, now is a good time to take a close look at what VCSE sector organisations need to know about getting involved in political campaigning.
Charities have a great record of engaging in public debate, giving a voice to their beneficiaries and causes. Local and national elections offer opportunities for charities to raise the profile of their causes, but they need to be particularly careful to maintain their independence and integrity.
The overarching message is to consider political campaigning carefully — especially in the run-up to elections.
The Charity Commission offers very detailed guidance on what is and is not permissible – especially during an election period. Let’s look at some key points.
The Commission clarifies campaigning as being about awareness-raising, educating or involving the public by mobilising their support on a particular issue, or to influence public attitudes. This is distinct from an activity which involves trying to secure support for, or opposition to, a change in the law or government or local authority policy, which is said to be ‘political activity’. Moreover, the public’s understanding of the terms ‘campaigning’ and ‘political activity’ can vary. ‘Political activity’ may be associated in people’s minds with party political activity.
This is worth repeating - political activity can only be undertaken by a charity in the context of supporting its charitable purposes. The Commission defines this as activity which is aimed at securing, or opposing, any change in the law or in the policy or decisions of government, local authorities or other public bodies. This differs from activity aimed at ensuring that an existing law is observed, which is part of campaigning.
Clearly, there is not always a fully clear demarcation between campaigning and political activity, and a charity might well undertake a phase of activity which has mixed elements.
Yes – if it supports and furthers its charitable purposes, unless its governing document prohibits it. Those activities must never be party-political.
No. Again, a charity must not undertake political activity that is not relevant to supporting the charity’s charitable purposes. Political activity might include:
Yes – so long as the document clearly states this is in support of furthering its charitable purposes.
Can a charity carry out political activity for a change in the law?
Yes – but only if it supports its charitable purposes.
Yes – but again, only if this supports its charitable purposes. And trustees must take care to avoid an approach which is purely focused on political activity as this could call into question the propriety of their actions, or even their charitable status.
If a campaign is directed at a private company the activity is not political – but trustees should still ask themselves whether the campaign is furthering the purposes of the charity.
Yes – but only on aspects that affect the charity’s beneficiaries. A political party might ask a charity for advice on its proposed policies. This is within the limits of how that input might impact upon the charity’s purposes.
Yes. As above, in objective furtherance of the charity’s defined purposes. The charity might ask candidates’ views on an issue and publish the response or host a public debate between candidates. But the charity must remain politically neutral to help ensure public perceptions of neutrality.
Last November, as part of the 2021 Norfolk VCSE Conference, CAN hosted a seminar on how to engage and influence Parliament to ensure the voices of those we support are heard. You can watch it here.
Charities need to take special care to ensure their political neutrality. A charity must not provide funds, or other resources, to a political candidate, nor encourage its supporters to support a particular candidate.
If a charity, deliberately or mistakenly, appears to be carrying out campaign activity that is not sufficiently connected to its purposes, the Charity Commission will investigate. It will aim to resolve such situations informally but may need to take regulatory action where there has been misuse of charity resources or misconduct.
Seemingly harmless social media posts can easily be taken out of context, because of their brevity and lack of scope to explain purpose. Charities must ensure their messages are clear and not perceived as being party political. MissionBox cites the case of a national charity which was investigated following a tweet about austerity and food poverty; the Charity Commission accepted that the charity wasn't acting in a party-political way but highlighted the need for need for clarity to avoid perception of political bias.
Law firm Mills and Reeve advises that "Even if their intention is not to act politically, charities must consider how the social media message will be interpreted and whether there is a risk the charity may be seen as political."
You can read more detail on The Charity Commission’s advice here.
You can read more advice on health checks for political campaigning here.
Non-profit advice group MissionBox covers similar points and cites examples of where charities have been unwittingly ‘caught out’ in the past - here. They also warn of care needed when using social media in political campaigning.
Perhaps the last word belongs to Helen Stephenson, CEO of the Charity Commission who, whilst warning of the hazards of political campaigning, pays tribute to the hard work of the VCSE sector here.